The Mathematical Derivation of Costs

In the text a graphical approach was used to explore the relationship between production and costs. This appendix provides a brief introduction to a more rigorous analysis based on calculus. A knowledge of multivariate differentiation is needed to understand this section.

The problem facing a firm is to minimize the cost of producing any given output. Production is achieved by combining inputs in the process illustrated by the production function Q=f(K,L) where for simplicity we restrict ourselves to two inputs. The marginal product for each good is the partial derivative of the function f with respect to each argument. That is, the marginal product of L is given by the formula MUL= f(K,L)/ L. Similarly, the marginal product of K is MUK= f(K,L)/ K. We assume that the second partial derivatives, 2f(K,L)/ L2 and 2f(K,L)/ K2 are negative to ensure diminishing marginal productivity in each input. Also assume the function f(K,L) is a smooth, continuous function and that an interior solution to the problem exists.

The firm minimizes costs, C=PkK+PlL holding output constant. To find the cost minimizing input combination we use the technique of Lagrangian multipliers. This Lagrange equation has the form L=(PkK+PlL)+l [Q-f(K,Y)]. L becomes the new function to be minimized, l is called the Lagrangian multiplier, and Q is the specific quantity we wish to produce.

The constrained maximum is found by treating l as a third variable in the problem, taking the partial derivatives of L with respect to each variable, and setting the results equal to zero. That is, derive each of the following equations:

L/ L = l Pl - f/ L = 0 (1)

L/ K = l Pk - f/ K = 0 (2)

L/ l = Q - f(K,L) = 0 (3)

These are called the first-order necessary conditions. Equation (3) is just the constraint holding Q constant. Equation (1) requires that the MPL=l Pl, and likewise equation (2) requires that MPK=l Pk. Rearranging gives that MPK/Pk=l and MPL/Pl=l . Thus, we find the condition, that MPL/Pl=MPK/Pk. The conditions we put on f(X,Y), smoothness, continuity, and that the function exhibit diminishing marginal productivity, ensures that this is a minimum, not a maximum.

As an example, suppose a firm has the production function Q=2L½Y½ and wants to minimize the cost of producing 200 units of output when the price of L is 4 and the price of K is 1. The Lagrangian function is L=(4L+K)+l [200-2L½K½]. The first-order necessary conditions for maximization are:

L/ K = 4 - ½l K-½L½ = 0 (4)

L/ L = 1 - ½l K½L-½ = 0 (5)

L/ l = 2L½K½-200 = 0 (6).

Reducing (4) and (5) gives K=4L which can be substituted into (6) to find 200-2(4L)½L½=0, or 200=4L which means that L=50 and K=200.

The easy way to do comparative statics is to just substitute alternative values for output or prices into the first-order necessary conditions. For example, if output were to fall to 100, but prices remained at 4 for L and 1 for K, consumption would change to K=100 and L=25. Alternatively, an increase in the price of K to 2, holding output at 200 and the price of L at 2 means that K=2L, L=70.70 and K=141.40.

We can also find the cost functions, that is cost as a function of output, by using the results of the cost minimization exercise. For example, when we used the production function 2L½K½ with the input prices Pl=4 and Pk=1 we found that cost minimization required that K=4L. Substituting this into the production function tells us that Q=4L, or alternatively, L=Q/4. Now total long run cost, LTC, is given by LTC=K+4L, which by substitution is LTC=8L, or LTC=2Q. Long run marginal cost (LMC) is LTC/ Q, which in this case is equal to 2. LMC is constant, which implies that LAC=LTC/Q=2 is constant also, and equal to LMC.

Short run cost curves are determined by holding K fixed, say at 25. then the short run production function becomes Q=2L½25½=10L½. By rearranging we can find that L=Q2/100. Short run total cost (STC) is STC=25+4L=25+Q2/25, and short run average cost (SAC), short run average variable cost (SAVC), short run average fixed cost (SAFC) and short run marginal cost (SMC) are given by:

SAC = 25/Q + Q/25 SAVC = Q/25

SAFC = 25/Q SMC = 2Q/25.

We find the economies of scale by looking at the long run average cost function. In this case the LAC is constant (at 2), so we know we have no economies or diseconomies of scale, is consistent with the production function which shows constant returns to scale.

Application Problems

1. Using the example production function from the appendix, show that both inputs exhibit diminishing marginal products. 2. Try various prices and outputs for K and L in the example from the appendix, and determine a general rule for allocation of costs across inputs with this type of production function. Also try Q=L¼K¾.

3. Suppose there is a third input, Z with a price of 2. The production function is 2K½L¼Z¼, and the output is 300. Find the cost minimizing input combination. Determine the changes if output falls to 200, or if the price of Z increases to 4.

4. For each of the production functions provided, find the short run average total, average variable, and marginal cost curves if K is fixed at 100.

5. For each of the production functions provided, determine the economies of scale.

6. Find a production function that shows economies of scale, and one that shows diseconomies of scale.

½